Peanut Butter, oatmeal, and peanut butter cups... 3 ingredients leading to positively perfect peanut buttery heaven. Add in those other cookie ingredients (flour, sugar, etc) and we have a cookie that tempted me to hide the batch and not share with a soul. Caught in the act, Liv and her brother twisted my arm eagerly grabbing what they claimed to be their "fair share". Needless to say, this batch didn't make it to morning.
Have you tried these Trader Joe's Mini Peanut Butter Cups?? Let me just say we had to return to the store more than once as they somehow seemed to evaporate before we actually got the cookies made. Little bites of peanut buttery awesomeness, they added an outrageously incredible bite to the soft, puffy cookies.
I must also note that the cookie dough test (we do test all of our cookie dough, but we suggest you do so at your own risk due to the raw egg content...) was unquestionably amazing. I may or may not have maneuvered my spoon gathering a few extra mini pb cups during the test, but I can without a doubt proclaim perfection.
Peanut Butter Lover's unite!! This cookie is for you!